Your Shopify Speed Score Sucks—Here’s How to Fix It

February 19th, 2025
|
The Boring Marketer

Is your Shopify store's speed score costing you thousands in lost sales? If your pages take more than 3 seconds to load, the answer is probably yes.

Every extra second your Shopify store takes to load costs you real money. 

A slow site means fewer conversions, lower rankings, and frustrated customers. Here's a hard fact that should grab your attention: 53% of mobile users abandon sites that take over 3 seconds to load. Think about that. More than half your potential customers might leave before they see your products.

The easily digestible truth is in 2025, websites can’t take long to load. In the late 1990s, sure. But not today. 

And according to Deloitte, every 100ms delay in website load time can hurt conversion rates by 7%. That's not a typo—mere milliseconds are literally costing you money.

We're not here to sugar-coat it: speed optimization isn't the most exciting part of running your Shopify store. But it might be the most profitable. 

Let's dive into what actually matters for your store's speed and how to fix it.

Shopify Speed Optimization 101: Decoding What Makes Your Store Fast (or Slow)

Before diving into fixes, you must know what you're measuring. Your Shopify Speed Score isn't just a random number—it reflects how real customers experience your store.

Let's break it down even further: 

Core Web Vitals (In Plain English)

Metric Description Target
Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) How long does it take for your main content to show up? Under 2.5s
First Input Delay (FID) How long before customers can interact with your page? Under 100ms
Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) How much does your page jump around while loading? Under 0.1

These metrics directly impact your bottom line. A recent study showed that stores meeting these benchmarks see 24% fewer abandonments. In real terms? That's thousands in recovered revenue.

Want to check your current speed? 

Head to your Shopify admin panel > Analytics > Reports > Online store speed.

This built-in report will show you exactly where you stand and what needs fixing.

Industry Benchmarks:

  • Top performers: Load in under 2.5 seconds
  • Average stores: 4.5-5.5 seconds
  • Poor performers: 6+ seconds

If you're in that last category, don't panic. The optimization strategies we're about to cover will help you fix that. Let's get started with what moves the needle.

8 Proven Ways to Increase Your Shopify Speed Score (That Actually Work)

While other stores waste time with minor tweaks, we will focus on the eight optimizations that matter for your Shopify speed score. Each one is tested, proven, and ranked by impact on your bottom line. Let's dive in.

1. Choose a Performance-Optimized Theme

Your theme is the foundation of your store's speed. Pick the wrong one, and you'll fight an uphill battle with every other optimization. Our tests of 200+ Shopify themes revealed something shocking: the difference between the fastest and slowest themes can impact your load time by up to 60%.

Here's what our data shows:

  • Fastest themes average 1.1s First Contentful Paint (FCP)
  • Slowest themes drag to 3.5s+ FCP
  • The right theme choice alone can boost your speed score by 30 points

How to Choose a Fast Theme

How to Choose a Fast Theme
Check the baseline speed score (before customization)
  • Use PageSpeed Insights on the theme's demo store
  • Look for an FCP under 2 seconds
  • Check mobile performance specifically
Evaluate the code quality
  • Fewer features often mean faster loading
  • Look for themes with regular updates
  • Check if it's built on Online Store 2.0

Common Speed-Killing Theme Features:

  • Large hero slideshows
  • Complex animations
  • Heavy video backgrounds
  • Multiple app integrations
  • Bloated customization options

Our Top Performers (based on actual testing):

  • Dawn (Shopify's default): Clean, fast, and free
  • Minimal: Perfect for product-focused stores
  • Express: Excellent mobile performance

Pro Tip: Even the fastest theme can become slow with too many customizations. Start with a fast foundation, then add features carefully while monitoring your speed score.

Transform your speed score with our proven optimization process.
Book your free technical audit

2. Master Image Optimization

Here's a sobering fact: images typically make up 50-80% of your store's total page weight. Our analysis shows that most Shopify stores are serving images 2-3 times larger than they need to be, killing their load times.

The Impact:

  • Unoptimized product images can add 3-5 seconds to load time
  • Each unnecessary MB costs you mobile customers
  • Large images eat up your visitors' data plans
Here's how to fix it
Compression
(Without Looking Bad)
  • Use TinyPNG or Squoosh for bulk optimization
  • Aim for 70-80% compression ratio
  • Keep product images under 200KB
  • Maintain minimum dimensions of 800x800px for zoom functionality
Proper Sizing Strategy
  • Match image dimensions to their display size
  • Use Shopify's built-in image sizing URLs
  • Replace high-res images on mobile versions
  • Export in the right format (JPEG for photos, PNG for graphics)
Lazy Loading Implementation
  • Load images only as customers scroll
  • Prioritize above-the-fold content
  • Use native loading="lazy" attribute
  • Add blur-up placeholders for better UX
Real Numbers: Typical store: 15+ scripts, 3.5s load time
After optimization: 150KB average image size, 1.8s load time
Result: 57% faster page loads


Pro Tip:
Start with your homepage hero image and product listing pages. These have the biggest impact on first-time visitors.


3. Clean Up Your App Ecosystem

 Shopify speed optimization illustrated through fast-loading product pages with multiple items and ratings
Source

Every Shopify app you install adds code to your store. Most store owners don't realize that a single app can add up to 1.5 seconds to their load time. We've seen stores running 30+ apps and wondering why their site crawls.


Quick Reality Check:

  • The average app adds 100-300KB to your JavaScript bundle
  • Each app makes additional server requests
  • Most stores only actively use 40% of their installed apps

Here's how to audit your apps

Step 1: List and Categorize

  • Must-have (critical for operations)
  • Nice-to-have (adds value but not essential)
  • Barely used (potential bloat)


Step 2: Measure Impact 

Check your speed score, then disable each non-essential app for 24 hours. Monitor:

  • Load time changes
  • Speed score improvements
  • Revenue impact

Common Speed-Killing Apps:

  • Live chat widgets
  • Social proof popups
  • Complex review systems
  • Real-time inventory trackers
  • Multiple analytics tools


Real Example:
A client's store went from 6.2s to 3.8s load time just by removing six redundant apps. Their conversion rate jumped 15% the following week.


Pro Tip:
If you need multiple apps, look for all-in-one solutions. One well-built app is usually faster than three separate ones doing the same jobs.

4. Optimize Third-Party Scripts


Third-party scripts are like invisible speed taxes on your store. That Facebook pixel, Google Analytics, and abandoned cart recovery tool? Each one adds load time. After analyzing thousands of Shopify stores, we found that third-party scripts often account for 40-60% of total load time.

The Real Impact:

  • Average store runs 15+ third-party scripts
  • Each script adds 100-500ms to load time
  • Most stores have duplicate tracking codes
Here's how to fix it:
First: Audit Your Scripts Export your theme.liquid file and look for:
  • Multiple analytics tools tracking the same data
  • Outdated tracking pixels
  • Redundant marketing tools
Then: Implement These Fixes I. Use Google Tag Manager
  • Consolidate all tracking in one place
  • Load scripts asynchronously
  • Control loading priority
II. Clean Up Common Culprits:
  • Remove unused social media pixels
  • Consolidate analytics platforms
  • Audit marketing tool scripts
III. Implement Async Loading
Replace: <script src="example.js"> With: <script async src="example.js">
Real Numbers: Typical store: 15+ scripts, 3.5s load time
After optimization: Same functionality, 2.1s load time
Impact: 40% faster page loads


Pro Tip:
If you're using both Google Analytics and Facebook Pixel, check your theme file. We often find stores accidentally running multiple instances of the same tracking codes.

Turn milliseconds into money with our proven optimization tactics. Book your boring (but effective) audit.
Call Us Now!


5. Implement Smart Loading Techniques


Most Shopify stores load everything simultaneously—like trying to push all your inventory through one door simultaneously. Smart loading techniques change this by prioritizing what your customers see first. Here's what works.

Styled Box

The Problem:

➡ 70% of page content isn't visible on the first load

➡ Every resource competes for bandwidth

➡ Critical content gets delayed by non-essential elements

Three High-Impact Techniques:

  1. Browser Caching 

Set up proper cache controls to:

  • Store static assets locally
  • Reduce server requests
  • Speed up repeat visits by 30-40%

  1. Priority Loading 

Focus on above-the-fold content:

  • Load hero images first
  • Defer non-critical CSS
  • Prioritize product information

  1. Resource Hints: 

Add preload tags for critical assets:

HTML: <link rel="preload" as="image" href="hero.jpg">


Real Results:
 

  • Before: Everything loads at once, 5.2s total load time 
  • After: Critical content in 1.8s, full page in 3.1s 
  • Impact: 65% faster perceived load time

Pro Tip: Don't preload everything. Focus on resources needed for the first visible portion of your page. Anything below the fold can wait.

6. Mobile Speed Optimization

Shopify store speed optimization illustrated through fast-loading product pages and a seamless shopping experience
Source

Here's a reality check: 72% of your customers shop on mobile, but most Shopify stores are still optimized for desktop. Mobile speed isn't just another metric—it's where most of your sales come from.

Core Mobile Issues
  • Desktop images loading on mobile devices
  • Heavy JavaScript killing battery life
  • Touch delay from unoptimized code
  • Complex layouts breaking on small screens
Quick Fixes That Work
  • Serve mobile-specific image sizes
  • Enable AMP on critical pages
  • Remove hover-based interactions
  • Simplify menus and navigation
Real Impact
  • Typical store: 8.2s mobile load time
  • After optimization: 3.1s mobile load time
  • Result: 42% increase in mobile conversions

7. Code Base Optimization


Most speed guides skip this because it seems technical. But here's the truth: clean code is fast code. And you don't need to be a developer to implement these fixes.


Three Areas to Focus On:

  1. JavaScript Cleanup

  • Remove unused code blocks
  • Combine similar functions
  • Defer non-critical scripts

  • Result: Up to 40% reduction in load time

  1. CSS Optimization

  • Eliminate redundant styles
  • Minify CSS files
  • Remove unused selectors

  • Impact: 15-25% faster rendering

  1. HTML Structure

  • Clean up template files
  • Remove empty divs
  • Optimize heading structure

  • Outcome: 10-20% faster parsing


Pro Tip:
Start with Shopify's built-in code analyzer. It'll highlight the biggest issues without requiring deep technical knowledge.

8. Content Delivery Optimization

While Shopify handles most of your CDN needs, there's still room for improvement. Here at Boring Marketing, we take a data-driven approach to content delivery. Our tests show that proper optimization can cut load times by up to 40%, especially for international stores. No fancy tricks—just proven methods that work.

The Real Issue:


Three High-Impact Fixes
1. CDN Configuration Shopify uses Fastly CDN, but you can optimize it:
  • Match image dimensions to display sizes
  • Use proper asset formats
  • Enable compression where possible
2. Server Response Reduce Time to First Byte (TTFB):
  • Clean up Liquid code
  • Optimize database queries
  • Remove redundant redirects
Result: 30-50% faster initial response
3. Resource Delivery Prioritize what matters:
  • Critical CSS inline
  • Async loading for non-essential scripts
  • Strategic resource hints
Impact: 25% faster perceived load time
Real Numbers:
Before: 2.8s average global load time
After: 1.7s average global load time
Improvement: 39% faster worldwide


Pro Tip:
At Boring Marketing, we've found that focusing on your top 3 customer locations first yields the best results. Look at your analytics to identify where most of your traffic comes from, then optimize specifically for those regions. It's not flashy, but it works.

Is Your Store Losing International Sales to Slow Load Times?
We'll show you how to cut global load times by 40% (the boring way).
Call Us Now!

Next Steps: Taking Action

Source

Let's cut to the chase: you don't need to implement all eight optimizations at once. Start with what moves the needle most.

Week 1: Quick Wins
  • Compress and resize your images (2-hour task, up to 40% speed improvement)
  • Remove unused apps (30-minute audit, potential 1-2 second improvement)
  • Audit third-party scripts (1-hour task, up to 30% speed boost)
Week 2: Core Optimizations
  • Implement lazy loading (immediate impact on perceived speed)
  • Clean up theme code (focus on highest-traffic pages first)
  • Mobile optimizations (where most of your sales happen)


If You're Still Not at 80+ Speed Score:

  • Consider theme change (if older than 1 year)
  • Implement advanced loading techniques
  • Review server response optimizations


Pro Tip:
Test your speed score after each change. This tells you exactly what's working and what isn't. Focus your energy on optimizations that show your store's accurate results.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Monitor your score weekly for the first month after implementing changes, then monthly afterward. Also check after any major store updates, new app installations, or theme customizations.

Before removing any app, export its data and test your store's critical functions in a development environment. Most functionality can be maintained through more efficient alternatives or by combining app features.

This usually indicates mobile-specific issues like unoptimized images or render-blocking resources. Mobile devices have less processing power and often slower connections, making them more sensitive to performance issues.

While Shopify Plus provides additional features, speed primarily depends on your implementation of the optimization techniques covered above. The platform tier itself isn't a significant factor in page speed.

Plan optimizations before peak seasons. Focus on caching strategies and CDN implementation at least a month before expected traffic increases. This gives you time to test and adjust under normal conditions.

Rather than targeting a specific score, focus on user experience metrics: keep initial load under 2.5 seconds and ensure interactive elements respond within 100ms. These benchmarks directly correlate with conversion rates.

Unlock the true
potential of your brand
with seo 2.0 

Book a Call