{
 "version": "v1",
 "date": "2026-11-19",
 "models": {
  "opus-5.5": "Claude Opus 5.5",
  "gpt-6.2-sol": "GPT-6.2 Sol",
  "gemini-4-neon": "Gemini 4 Neon"
 },
 "judges": [
  "Claude Fable 5.2",
  "GPT-6.2 Astra",
  "Gemini 4 Carbon"
 ],
 "creative": {
  "pieces": 110,
  "brands": 35,
  "votes_model_vs_model": 660,
  "rating": {
   "gemini-4-neon": 978.9,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 1022.2,
   "opus-5.5": 998.9
  },
  "rating_95": {
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    943.9,
    1007.4
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    991.6,
    1051.6
   ],
   "opus-5.5": [
    968.8,
    1028.9
   ]
  },
  "win_rate_by_channel": {
   "instagram": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.408,
     "lo": 0.309,
     "hi": 0.507,
     "votes": 152,
     "jobs": 38
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.671,
     "lo": 0.559,
     "hi": 0.783,
     "votes": 152,
     "jobs": 38
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.421,
     "lo": 0.316,
     "hi": 0.533,
     "votes": 152,
     "jobs": 38
    }
   },
   "meta-ads": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.641,
     "lo": 0.5,
     "hi": 0.781,
     "votes": 64,
     "jobs": 16
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.344,
     "lo": 0.188,
     "hi": 0.531,
     "votes": 64,
     "jobs": 16
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.516,
     "lo": 0.328,
     "hi": 0.703,
     "votes": 64,
     "jobs": 16
    }
   },
   "x": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.625,
     "lo": 0.477,
     "hi": 0.761,
     "votes": 88,
     "jobs": 22
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.648,
     "lo": 0.534,
     "hi": 0.75,
     "votes": 88,
     "jobs": 22
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.227,
     "lo": 0.102,
     "hi": 0.375,
     "votes": 88,
     "jobs": 22
    }
   },
   "youtube": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.449,
     "lo": 0.338,
     "hi": 0.559,
     "votes": 136,
     "jobs": 34
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.441,
     "lo": 0.309,
     "hi": 0.566,
     "votes": 136,
     "jobs": 34
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.61,
     "lo": 0.493,
     "hi": 0.721,
     "votes": 136,
     "jobs": 34
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "vs_brand": {
  "All channels": {
   "vs_proven_winners": 0.192,
   "vs_flops": 0.317
  },
  "Instagram posts": {
   "vs_proven_winners": 0.079,
   "vs_flops": 0.061
  },
  "Meta ads": {
   "vs_proven_winners": 0.104,
   "vs_flops": 0.25
  },
  "X posts": {
   "vs_proven_winners": 0.048,
   "vs_flops": 0.167
  },
  "YouTube": {
   "vs_proven_winners": 0.464,
   "vs_flops": 0.73
  }
 },
 "deep": {
  "rating": {
   "opus-5.5": 1020.1,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 1060.4,
   "gemini-4-neon": 919.5
  },
  "rating_95": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    987.4,
    1064.5
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    987.9,
    1127.3
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    833.8,
    983.0
   ]
  },
  "win_rate_by_job": {
   "page": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.625,
     "lo": 0.406,
     "hi": 0.844,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.562,
     "lo": 0.312,
     "hi": 0.812,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.312,
     "lo": 0.094,
     "hi": 0.594,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    }
   },
   "email": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.625,
     "lo": 0.5,
     "hi": 0.812,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.688,
     "lo": 0.375,
     "hi": 1.0,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.188,
     "lo": 0.0,
     "hi": 0.375,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    }
   },
   "positioning": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.656,
     "lo": 0.5,
     "hi": 0.812,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.75,
     "lo": 0.562,
     "hi": 0.906,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.094,
     "lo": 0.031,
     "hi": 0.188,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    }
   },
   "plan": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.5,
     "lo": 0.344,
     "hi": 0.625,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.906,
     "lo": 0.812,
     "hi": 0.969,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.094,
     "lo": 0.0,
     "hi": 0.219,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    }
   },
   "video": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.469,
     "lo": 0.281,
     "hi": 0.625,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.281,
     "lo": 0.062,
     "hi": 0.531,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.75,
     "lo": 0.531,
     "hi": 0.938,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    }
   },
   "carousel": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "rate": 0.375,
     "lo": 0.188,
     "hi": 0.625,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "rate": 0.562,
     "lo": 0.25,
     "hi": 0.812,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "rate": 0.562,
     "lo": 0.25,
     "hi": 0.875,
     "votes": 32,
     "jobs": 8
    }
   }
  },
  "shorter_won": [
   0.549,
   288
  ],
  "length_adjusted": {
   "rating": {
    "opus-5.5": 1013.9,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 1143.7,
    "gemini-4-neon": 842.4
   },
   "beta_log_length": 1.281
  },
  "checks_pass_rate": {
   "opus-5.5": 0.618,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.636,
   "gemini-4-neon": 0.557
  },
  "client_ready": {
   "opus-5.5": {
    "honest": 0.792,
    "phone": 0.875,
    "cta": 1.0,
    "subjects": 0.9583333333333334,
    "length": 0.5625,
    "adtext": 1.0,
    "slides": 0.875,
    "big_text": 0.9591836734693877,
    "real_product": 0.19
   },
   "gpt-6.2-sol": {
    "honest": 1.0,
    "phone": 1.0,
    "cta": 1.0,
    "subjects": 0.9583333333333334,
    "length": 1.0,
    "adtext": 1.0,
    "slides": 1.0,
    "big_text": 0.0,
    "real_product": 0.06
   },
   "gemini-4-neon": {
    "honest": 0.896,
    "phone": 0.875,
    "cta": 1.0,
    "subjects": 0.8333333333333334,
    "length": 0.9375,
    "adtext": 1.0,
    "slides": 1.0,
    "big_text": 0.0,
    "real_product": 0.06
   }
  }
 },
 "copy": {
  "win_rate": {
   "opus-5.5": 0.512,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.573,
   "gemini-4-neon": 0.415
  },
  "by_angle": {
   "customer": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.575,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.481,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.444
   },
   "copywriter": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.512,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.569,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.419
   },
   "brand": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.45,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.669,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.381
   },
   "all": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.512,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.573,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.415
   }
  },
  "agreement": {
   "customer | copywriter": [
    0.796,
    240
   ],
   "customer | brand": [
    0.496,
    240
   ],
   "copywriter | brand": [
    0.533,
    240
   ]
  },
  "vs_flop": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    0.781,
    32
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    0.688,
    32
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    0.562,
    32
   ]
  },
  "honesty": {
   "opus-5.5": 0.9,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 1.0,
   "gemini-4-neon": 0.975
  },
  "by_job": {
   "salescopy": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.365,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.781,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.354
   },
   "headlines": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.594,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.51,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.396
   },
   "search_ad": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.417,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.385,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.698
   },
   "cold_email": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.521,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.917,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.062
   },
   "product_copy": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.542,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.396,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.562
   },
   "rewrite": {
    "opus-5.5": 0.656,
    "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.531,
    "gemini-4-neon": 0.312
   }
  }
 },
 "writing": {
  "pieces": 704,
  "labelers": [
   "qwen/qwen4-max",
   "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro"
  ],
  "agreement": {
   "hook": 0.729,
   "framework": 0.589,
   "register": 0.685,
   "cta": 0.872
  },
  "by_model": {
   "opus-5.5": {
    "pieces": 198,
    "metrics": {
     "grade": 6.15,
     "words_per_sentence": 9.02,
     "you_per_100": 2.91,
     "we_per_100": 0.76,
     "numbers_per_100": 5.36,
     "questions": 0.71,
     "exclamations": 0.05,
     "em_dashes_per_100": 0.01,
     "ai_tells_per_100": 0.06
    },
    "hook": {
     "product_name_or_label": 0.364,
     "question": 0.136,
     "outcome_or_benefit": 0.13,
     "news_or_announcement": 0.091,
     "command": 0.058,
     "story_or_scene": 0.052,
     "pain_or_problem": 0.045,
     "number_or_stat": 0.045,
     "offer_or_price": 0.039,
     "curiosity_gap": 0.019,
     "social_proof": 0.019
    },
    "framework": {
     "announcement": 0.234,
     "how_to_or_list": 0.178,
     "attention_interest_desire_action": 0.131,
     "problem_agitate_solve": 0.121,
     "offer_led": 0.093,
     "feature_list": 0.093,
     "proof_led": 0.075,
     "benefit_stack": 0.037,
     "story": 0.028,
     "comparison_or_us_vs_them": 0.009
    },
    "register": {
     "professional": 0.563,
     "conversational": 0.405,
     "casual": 0.024,
     "hype": 0.008
    },
    "cta": {
     "direct": 0.606,
     "none": 0.282,
     "soft": 0.112
    },
    "proof": {
     "numbers": 0.51,
     "none": 0.313,
     "reviews_or_testimonials": 0.227,
     "named_customers": 0.146,
     "awards_or_press": 0.121,
     "guarantee": 0.116
    }
   },
   "gpt-6.2-sol": {
    "pieces": 198,
    "metrics": {
     "grade": 6.08,
     "words_per_sentence": 9.23,
     "you_per_100": 2.63,
     "we_per_100": 0.4,
     "numbers_per_100": 4.23,
     "questions": 0.59,
     "exclamations": 0.02,
     "em_dashes_per_100": 0.12,
     "ai_tells_per_100": 0.02
    },
    "hook": {
     "product_name_or_label": 0.411,
     "question": 0.177,
     "command": 0.113,
     "outcome_or_benefit": 0.113,
     "number_or_stat": 0.043,
     "news_or_announcement": 0.043,
     "pain_or_problem": 0.035,
     "story_or_scene": 0.028,
     "offer_or_price": 0.021,
     "curiosity_gap": 0.014
    },
    "framework": {
     "how_to_or_list": 0.244,
     "announcement": 0.16,
     "feature_list": 0.143,
     "attention_interest_desire_action": 0.118,
     "offer_led": 0.084,
     "problem_agitate_solve": 0.067,
     "story": 0.067,
     "benefit_stack": 0.067,
     "proof_led": 0.034,
     "comparison_or_us_vs_them": 0.017
    },
    "register": {
     "professional": 0.582,
     "conversational": 0.388,
     "casual": 0.03
    },
    "cta": {
     "direct": 0.532,
     "none": 0.376,
     "soft": 0.092
    },
    "proof": {
     "none": 0.49,
     "numbers": 0.333,
     "reviews_or_testimonials": 0.106,
     "awards_or_press": 0.066,
     "named_customers": 0.061,
     "guarantee": 0.051
    }
   },
   "gemini-4-neon": {
    "pieces": 198,
    "metrics": {
     "grade": 8.16,
     "words_per_sentence": 12.64,
     "you_per_100": 2.39,
     "we_per_100": 0.54,
     "numbers_per_100": 5.59,
     "questions": 0.65,
     "exclamations": 0.05,
     "em_dashes_per_100": 0.69,
     "ai_tells_per_100": 0.12
    },
    "hook": {
     "product_name_or_label": 0.397,
     "command": 0.088,
     "outcome_or_benefit": 0.081,
     "question": 0.074,
     "number_or_stat": 0.074,
     "offer_or_price": 0.074,
     "pain_or_problem": 0.066,
     "curiosity_gap": 0.066,
     "news_or_announcement": 0.059,
     "story_or_scene": 0.015,
     "social_proof": 0.007
    },
    "framework": {
     "how_to_or_list": 0.223,
     "announcement": 0.205,
     "attention_interest_desire_action": 0.161,
     "feature_list": 0.08,
     "problem_agitate_solve": 0.071,
     "offer_led": 0.071,
     "proof_led": 0.062,
     "benefit_stack": 0.054,
     "story": 0.045,
     "comparison_or_us_vs_them": 0.027
    },
    "register": {
     "professional": 0.757,
     "conversational": 0.229,
     "casual": 0.014
    },
    "cta": {
     "direct": 0.642,
     "none": 0.301,
     "soft": 0.057
    },
    "proof": {
     "numbers": 0.535,
     "none": 0.303,
     "reviews_or_testimonials": 0.232,
     "named_customers": 0.162,
     "guarantee": 0.126,
     "awards_or_press": 0.116
    }
   },
   "brand": {
    "pieces": 110,
    "metrics": {
     "grade": 6.72,
     "words_per_sentence": 9.06,
     "you_per_100": 3.13,
     "we_per_100": 0.96,
     "numbers_per_100": 2.23,
     "questions": 0.13,
     "exclamations": 0.05,
     "em_dashes_per_100": 0.22,
     "ai_tells_per_100": 0.15
    },
    "hook": {
     "product_name_or_label": 0.256,
     "curiosity_gap": 0.134,
     "news_or_announcement": 0.122,
     "number_or_stat": 0.11,
     "command": 0.11,
     "question": 0.073,
     "outcome_or_benefit": 0.073,
     "pain_or_problem": 0.061,
     "story_or_scene": 0.049,
     "social_proof": 0.012
    },
    "framework": {
     "announcement": 0.338,
     "how_to_or_list": 0.208,
     "story": 0.143,
     "problem_agitate_solve": 0.104,
     "benefit_stack": 0.065,
     "attention_interest_desire_action": 0.052,
     "comparison_or_us_vs_them": 0.039,
     "proof_led": 0.026,
     "offer_led": 0.013,
     "feature_list": 0.013
    },
    "register": {
     "professional": 0.5,
     "casual": 0.256,
     "conversational": 0.244
    },
    "cta": {
     "none": 0.547,
     "direct": 0.253,
     "soft": 0.2
    },
    "proof": {
     "none": 0.755,
     "numbers": 0.091,
     "awards_or_press": 0.009,
     "named_customers": 0.009
    }
   }
  },
  "votes": 1668,
  "wins_with": {
   "hook": {
    "question": [
     0.585,
     94
    ],
    "number_or_stat": [
     0.516,
     64
    ],
    "pain_or_problem": [
     0.54,
     50
    ],
    "outcome_or_benefit": [
     0.559,
     118
    ],
    "news_or_announcement": [
     0.321,
     28
    ],
    "curiosity_gap": [
     0.458,
     24
    ],
    "command": [
     0.476,
     124
    ],
    "story_or_scene": [
     0.324,
     34
    ],
    "social_proof": [
     0.35,
     20
    ],
    "offer_or_price": [
     0.609,
     46
    ],
    "product_name_or_label": [
     0.464,
     138
    ]
   },
   "framework": {
    "problem_agitate_solve": [
     0.722,
     36
    ],
    "attention_interest_desire_action": [
     0.276,
     58
    ],
    "feature_list": [
     0.542,
     24
    ],
    "benefit_stack": [
     0.429,
     14
    ],
    "how_to_or_list": [
     0.75,
     16
    ],
    "proof_led": [
     0.429,
     14
    ],
    "offer_led": [
     0.676,
     34
    ],
    "announcement": [
     0.316,
     38
    ]
   },
   "register": {
    "casual": [
     0.5,
     18
    ],
    "conversational": [
     0.581,
     136
    ],
    "professional": [
     0.405,
     126
    ]
   },
   "cta": {
    "direct": [
     0.289,
     152
    ],
    "soft": [
     0.71,
     124
    ],
    "none": [
     0.568,
     88
    ]
   },
   "proof": {
    "numbers": [
     0.49,
     296
    ],
    "reviews_or_testimonials": [
     0.385,
     156
    ],
    "named_customers": [
     0.359,
     156
    ],
    "awards_or_press": [
     0.466,
     116
    ],
    "guarantee": [
     0.59,
     100
    ],
    "none": [
     0.523,
     260
    ]
   }
  },
  "wins_when_more": {
   "grade": [
    0.421,
    1612
   ],
   "words": [
    0.475,
    1586
   ],
   "you_per_100": [
    0.507,
    1368
   ],
   "numbers_per_100": [
    0.453,
    1348
   ],
   "questions": [
    0.528,
    578
   ],
   "em_dashes_per_100": [
    0.444,
    574
   ],
   "ai_tells_per_100": [
    0.493,
    296
   ]
  },
  "real_hits_vs_flops": {
   "hook": {
    "question": [
     4,
     2
    ],
    "number_or_stat": [
     4,
     5
    ],
    "pain_or_problem": [
     0,
     5
    ],
    "outcome_or_benefit": [
     4,
     2
    ],
    "news_or_announcement": [
     6,
     4
    ],
    "curiosity_gap": [
     6,
     5
    ],
    "command": [
     4,
     5
    ],
    "story_or_scene": [
     2,
     2
    ],
    "product_name_or_label": [
     11,
     10
    ]
   },
   "framework": {
    "problem_agitate_solve": [
     2,
     6
    ],
    "attention_interest_desire_action": [
     2,
     2
    ],
    "benefit_stack": [
     2,
     3
    ],
    "story": [
     7,
     4
    ],
    "comparison_or_us_vs_them": [
     2,
     1
    ],
    "how_to_or_list": [
     9,
     7
    ],
    "announcement": [
     13,
     13
    ]
   },
   "register": {
    "casual": [
     12,
     9
    ],
    "conversational": [
     9,
     11
    ],
    "professional": [
     23,
     18
    ]
   },
   "cta": {
    "direct": [
     12,
     12
    ],
    "soft": [
     6,
     13
    ],
    "none": [
     28,
     24
    ]
   },
   "metrics": {
    "grade": [
     6.73,
     6.72
    ],
    "words": [
     24.29,
     34.16
    ],
    "you_per_100": [
     3.13,
     3.13
    ],
    "numbers_per_100": [
     2.03,
     2.42
    ],
    "questions": [
     0.11,
     0.15
    ],
    "em_dashes_per_100": [
     0.42,
     0.02
    ]
   },
   "n": [
    55,
    55
   ]
  }
 },
 "seo": {
  "stamp": "seo-v1-2026-11-20",
  "votes": 176,
  "all": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    0.358,
    120
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    0.575,
    120
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    0.571,
    112
   ]
  },
  "kind": {
   "kw_plan": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.234,
     64
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.625,
     64
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.641,
     64
    ]
   },
   "seo_page": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.5,
     56
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.518,
     56
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.479,
     48
    ]
   }
  },
  "kind_lens": {
   "kw_plan": {
    "seo": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.156,
      32
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.625,
      32
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.719,
      32
     ]
    },
    "brand": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.312,
      32
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.625,
      32
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.562,
      32
     ]
    }
   },
   "seo_page": {
    "searcher": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.607,
      28
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.5,
      28
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.375,
      24
     ]
    },
    "seo": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.393,
      28
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.536,
      28
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.583,
      24
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  "vs_top": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    0.688,
    32
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    0.781,
    32
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    0.75,
    24
   ]
  },
  "honesty": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    0.429,
    [
     [
      "notion-seo_page",
      [
       "These free templates give you a structure from the first line:",
       "It has a cue column, a notes area, and a summary, ready for every lecture.",
       "and you can start from free templates such as Cornell notes and flashcards."
      ]
     ],
     [
      "ridge-seo_page",
      [
       "They're built for front-pocket, everyday carry, not for holding everything you've ever been handed at a checkout."
      ]
     ],
     [
      "solo-stove-seo_page",
      [
       "The fire pit and the sticks arrive together.",
       "No rating published"
      ]
     ],
     [
      "kosas-seo_page",
      [
       "It is buildable enough to brighten shadows and still looks like skin.",
       "Kosas makes [Revealer Extra Bright, a serum-powered color corrector](https://kosas.com/products/revealer-extra-bright), to pair with Revealer Concealer.",
       "Revealer was inspired by a founder whose sensitive, acne-prone skin got worse from wearing makeup."
      ]
     ]
    ]
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    1.0,
    []
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    0.833,
    [
     [
      "solo-stove-seo_page",
      [
       "If you prefer push-button convenience"
      ]
     ]
    ]
   ]
  },
  "code": {
   "kw_plan": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "keywords": 12.875,
     "invented_keywords": 0.125,
     "volumes_exact": 1.0,
     "difficulty_exact": 1.0,
     "already_top3": 0.0,
     "duplicates": 0.0,
     "existing_urls_not_in_data": 0.125,
     "total_volume": 83387.5,
     "avg_difficulty": 20.637
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "keywords": 12.5,
     "invented_keywords": 0.0,
     "volumes_exact": 1.0,
     "difficulty_exact": 1.0,
     "already_top3": 0.0,
     "duplicates": 0.0,
     "existing_urls_not_in_data": 0.25,
     "total_volume": 96803.75,
     "avg_difficulty": 19.525
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "keywords": 15.0,
     "invented_keywords": 0.0,
     "volumes_exact": 1.0,
     "difficulty_exact": 1.0,
     "already_top3": 0.0,
     "duplicates": 0.0,
     "existing_urls_not_in_data": 0.0,
     "total_volume": 87247.5,
     "avg_difficulty": 14.625
    }
   },
   "seo_page": {
    "opus-5.5": {
     "words": 1104.625,
     "title_chars": 52.875,
     "title_ok": 1.0,
     "meta_chars": 139.5,
     "meta_ok": 1.0,
     "h1_count": 1.0,
     "keyword_in_title": 1.0,
     "keyword_in_h1": 1.0,
     "internal_links": 5.25,
     "links_not_in_data": 0.0,
     "over_length": 0.125
    },
    "gpt-6.2-sol": {
     "words": 517.25,
     "title_chars": 50.25,
     "title_ok": 1.0,
     "meta_chars": 138.125,
     "meta_ok": 1.0,
     "h1_count": 1.0,
     "keyword_in_title": 1.0,
     "keyword_in_h1": 1.0,
     "internal_links": 3.125,
     "links_not_in_data": 0.0,
     "over_length": 0.0
    },
    "gemini-4-neon": {
     "words": 1031.167,
     "title_chars": 55.167,
     "title_ok": 1.0,
     "meta_chars": 145.667,
     "meta_ok": 1.0,
     "h1_count": 0.833,
     "keyword_in_title": 1.0,
     "keyword_in_h1": 0.833,
     "internal_links": 5.0,
     "links_not_in_data": 0.0,
     "over_length": 0.0
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "edit": {
  "stamp": "edit-v1-2026-11-20",
  "votes": 50,
  "feed": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    0.769,
    26
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    0.231,
    26
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    0.5,
    20
   ]
  },
  "watch": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    0.643,
    14
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    0.357,
    14
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    null,
    0
   ]
  },
  "made": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    8,
    8
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    8,
    8
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    5,
    8
   ]
  },
  "repair_rounds": {
   "opus-5.5": 1.12,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 1.88,
   "gemini-4-neon": 2.12
  },
  "cost": {
   "opus-5.5": 2.34,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 1.23,
   "gemini-4-neon": 7.37
  },
  "checks": {
   "opus-5.5": {
    "hook_frame0": 1.0,
    "captions": 1.0,
    "product_early": 0.5,
    "proof": 0.93,
    "offer": 1.0,
    "end_card": 1.0,
    "safe_zone": 0.64,
    "edited": 0.86,
    "clean": 0.57,
    "native": 0.07
   },
   "gpt-6.2-sol": {
    "hook_frame0": 0.86,
    "captions": 1.0,
    "product_early": 0.57,
    "proof": 0.79,
    "offer": 1.0,
    "end_card": 1.0,
    "safe_zone": 0.79,
    "edited": 0.0,
    "clean": 0.79,
    "native": 0.0
   },
   "gemini-4-neon": {
    "hook_frame0": 0.88,
    "captions": 1.0,
    "product_early": 0.5,
    "proof": 0.88,
    "offer": 1.0,
    "end_card": 1.0,
    "safe_zone": 0.5,
    "edited": 1.0,
    "clean": 0.62,
    "native": 0.0
   }
  },
  "honesty": {
   "opus-5.5": 1.0,
   "gpt-6.2-sol": 1.0,
   "gemini-4-neon": 1.0
  }
 },
 "neutral": {
  "votes": 1304,
  "by_run": {
   "copy": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.656,
     320
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.419,
     320
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.425,
     320
    ]
   },
   "copy:kinds": {
    "cold_email": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.781,
      32
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.719,
      32
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.0,
      32
     ]
    },
    "headlines": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.828,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.219,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.453,
      64
     ]
    },
    "product_copy": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.656,
      32
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.281,
      32
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.562,
      32
     ]
    },
    "rewrite": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.891,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.375,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.234,
      64
     ]
    },
    "salescopy": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.453,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.656,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.391,
      64
     ]
    },
    "search_ad": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.391,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.344,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.766,
      64
     ]
    }
   },
   "deep": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.573,
     384
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.578,
     384
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.349,
     384
    ]
   },
   "deep:kinds": {
    "carousel": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.438,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.406,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.656,
      64
     ]
    },
    "email": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.719,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.641,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.141,
      64
     ]
    },
    "page": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.656,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.484,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.359,
      64
     ]
    },
    "plan": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.469,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.984,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.047,
      64
     ]
    },
    "positioning": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.812,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.578,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.109,
      64
     ]
    },
    "video": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.344,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.375,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.781,
      64
     ]
    }
   },
   "edit": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.731,
     52
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.212,
     52
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.575,
     40
    ]
   },
   "edit:kinds": {
    "edit": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.731,
      52
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.212,
      52
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.575,
      40
     ]
    }
   },
   "seo": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.45,
     120
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.433,
     120
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.625,
     112
    ]
   },
   "seo:kinds": {
    "kw_plan": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.312,
      64
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.5,
      64
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.688,
      64
     ]
    },
    "seo_page": {
     "opus-5.5": [
      0.607,
      56
     ],
     "gpt-6.2-sol": [
      0.357,
      56
     ],
     "gemini-4-neon": [
      0.542,
      48
     ]
    }
   }
  },
  "by_judge": {
   "kimi-k3.1-pro": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.619,
     438
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.466,
     438
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.414,
     428
    ]
   },
   "qwen4-max": {
    "opus-5.5": [
     0.573,
     438
    ],
    "gpt-6.2-sol": [
     0.491,
     438
    ],
    "gemini-4-neon": [
     0.435,
     428
    ]
   }
  },
  "agreement": {
   "copy": [
    0.872,
    187
   ],
   "deep": [
    0.888,
    249
   ],
   "edit": [
    0.903,
    31
   ],
   "seo": [
    0.773,
    66
   ]
  },
  "all": {
   "opus-5.5": [
    0.596,
    876
   ],
   "gpt-6.2-sol": [
    0.478,
    876
   ],
   "gemini-4-neon": [
    0.424,
    856
   ]
  }
 },
 "cost_per_job": {
  "opus-5.5": 0.0779,
  "gpt-6.2-sol": 0.0305,
  "gemini-4-neon": 0.1574
 }
}